Biographies on Andrew Stoltmann, Dave Neuman and Joe Wojciechowski Stoltmann In The News Stoltmann Arbitration Awards Checking Out Brokers & Advisers 151 Answers To Most FAQs Group Arbitration Actions Contact & Disclaimer

Helping individuals recover their investment and retirement plan losses.


Stoltmann in the News


Long Beach Press-Telegram, November 10, 2002 (Humberto Cruz)

Q: Many people rely on the advice of a stockbroker. When my wife and I got into stocks a few years ago, we did so without doing much research. That is our fault.

But our broker never said much about diversifying. We've seen many of our stocks go down. Many of the stocks his firm recommended to other clients have done quite poorly. Do we have a case against this broker and his firm? A: Without knowing more, I don't want to go out on a limb. But based on what you tell me, you might have a case.

"Brokers have an obligation to see that their clients' accounts are properly diversified,' said Andrew Stoltmann, a former broker and now an attorney in the Chicago office of Maddox, Hargett & Caruso P.C., which represents investors in arbitration cases against brokerage firms. "To the extent a broker did not do this, he might be liable,' Stoltmann said.

Claims against brokers are being filed at a record pace, and failure to diversify is the complaint Stoltmann said he has seen most often as part of the broad category of unsuitable investment recommendations.

Other common complaints include misrepresentation, such as a broker failing to properly disclose the risks of an investment; excessive or unauthorized trading, and a brokerage firm's failure to su pervise a broker.

The number of claims is on a pace to break last year's record of 6,915, according to figures from the National Association of Securities Dealers, a self-regulatory group for the brokerage industry. [For the latest numbers and to learn about the claim process, go to the NASD Dispute Resolution Web site, www.nasdadr.com].

The surge in claims is in lockstep with the steep losses many investors have suffered in what has become the second worst bear market in U.S. history. "The case filings are through the roof and will continue as the market continues to retreat and expose the misdeeds of brokers,' said Stoltmann, who also worked as a law clerk at the NASD for two years.

Just because you lose money in an investment does not mean the broker is at fault, of course. And most brokers I know are caring and dedicated professionals. Even well-diversified portfolios have suffered in the broad-based market decline.

The question in deciding whether you have a case is whether your broker exercised his fiduciary duty to watch out for your best interests, including monitoring your investments.

"If you have a losing investment, the question is, should you have been in that investment?' said Bruce Sankin, of Coral Springs, Fla., an arbitrator before the NASD since 1992 and a mediator since 1996. [Mediation is a less expensive and less formal procedure in which the investor and brokerage firm try to settle a dispute.]

The answer goes back to the suitability issue was the investment proper for the investor, given his goals and risk tolerance? But it also assumes that the broker kept an eye on your account and continued to advise you.

If the broker advised the client it was better to hold to his investments and ride out the market decline, that's one thing provided the investments were suitable to begin with.

But if the broker never bothered to call the client while the market tanked the past two years Sankin said he knows of cases like that that's another story.

"A broker has your account information and he sees your statement every month,' Sankin said. "If a broker does not keep in touch, he cannot hold out himself to be a financial adviser. I cannot see an investor losing $20,000, $30,000 or $50,000 without their financial adviser talking to them.'

About Our Lawyers
Learn more about Andrew Stoltmann, Dave Neuman and Joe Wojciechowski

Stoltmann In The News
Various news articles and TV transcripts quoting Andrew Stoltmann or profiling his clients.

Stoltmann Arbitration Awards
Arbitration Awards by Andrew Stoltmann.

InvestmentFraud.PRO Blog
Read the InvestmentFraud.PRO Blog.

Arbitration Process
Questions and Answers on the Arbitration Process.

Checking Out Your Broker
Tips for Checking Out Brokers and Advisers.

151 Answers To Most Faqs.
Excerpts from the book by co-authored by Andrew Stoltmann on Investor Rights for the 21st Century.

Group Arbitration Actions
Learn more about Group Arbitration Actions.

Insurance Abuses
Life Insurance Twisting

Ponzi Scheme
Scheme usually offers abnormally high short-term returns...

Bond Fraud
At Stoltmann Law Offices, we've represented many clients in arbitrations ...

Get Started, Schedule A Meeting.
Contact our office to schedule a meeting.

Cases Pending/Current Investigations
Specific broker’s/brokerage firm’s name and actions

Free, 24 Hour, Online Evaluation
Contact our office to schedule a meeting.



Andrew Stoltmann analyzes the guilty verdict reached in the corporate fraud trial of former Tyco CEO Dennis Kozlowski with CNBC anchor Ron Isana.


Andrew Stoltmann debates the impact a criminal indictment would have on accounting giant KPMG with Maria Bartiromo on CNBC's "Closing Bell" on June 16, 2005.


Andrew Stoltmann discusses the overturn of the Arthur Anderson criminal conviction by the U.S. Supreme Court.


Andrew Stoltmann provides commentary on former Cendant Vice Chairman Kirk Shelton's 10 year prison sentence and $3.3 billion restitution ordered by U.S. District Judge Alvin Thompson in August of 2005.


Andrew Stoltmann analyzes the Richard Scrushy not guilty jury verdict in June of 2005 on CNBC.


Andrew Stoltmann discusses a possible criminal indictment against Tenet Healthcare for its failure to evacuate patients during Hurricane Katrina.


Andrew Stoltmann discusses
the $253 million Vioxx verdict in
August of 2005 against Merck with
CNBC anchor Maria Bartiromo.